Bruce believes hes chosen Rachel, but ends up saving Harvey. The gambit itself is really part of the bigger thesis The Dark Knight tries to lay out: That one man trying to save a city whether he wears a mask or does it in broad daylight is an inherently impossible task. What was a Progressive goal A. In an attempt to stop him, Alfred finally confessed to Bruce that Rachel chose Dent and that he burned the letter in order to spare Bruce pain. Stack Exchange Network. Did you see the look on Batman's face when he saw it was Dent? With Harvey Dent still dead, but without any of the incriminating acts that would compromise his legacy, the Dent Act and Commissioner Jim Gordons career would both be intact. Answer (1 of 23): Easy. She was in great pain. As Harvey Dent is now dead, this kicks off two important events that would change the ending of The Dark Knight. The Dark Knight saw the demise of Rachel Dawes after the Joker tricked Batman and the police and only let them save Harvey Dent or her. Everything was worked out in due time, and the character, as well as the film, went on full steam ahead without Holmes, for better or worse. You are giving birth to another son., 18Rachel died while giving birth to the son. Too often in the film industry, the story behindBatman recastsand others can be incredibly ugly and set the rumor mill ablaze. 4. Nolans Batman saved Harvey Dent alone but Batman never works alone. She urged Bruce not to give up faith in other people, even if she had disappointed him. Rachel was very clearly conscious the entire time whereas Harvey was unconscious and woke up to her yelling. Shane started at Screen Rant in late 2019. After Bruce's parents were murdered by Joe Chill, Rachel's mother sought other employment and left Wayne Manor with Rachel.[1]. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Not very clever to chance Rachel's death, if Batman loved her. Please refresh the page and try again. She urges Bruce not to give up faith in other people, even if she has disappointed him. where Rachel died). Joker just knew addresses but didn't know who was where. But in order to maintain that level of endearment, those moments have to be executed precisely. Alfred just imagines Bruce Wayne in the cafe with Selina Kyle aka Batman has friends, and peers like Nightwing, Robin, Batgirl, Batwoman, and so on, who are his equals on just about every count. The Joker lied because he wanted Dent to live and lose his mind over Rachel's death, and he knew that Batman and Rachel had something going on. JOKER: Hi. They later faked their deaths to leave Gotham, began a relationship, and Bruce had passed his legacy as Gotham's protector to John Blake, also proving Rachel wrong in her belief that he would not give up being the Batman.[3]. In Batman Begins, Dawes was played by Katie Holmes, only for the actress to suddenly be replaced by Maggie Gyllenhaal inThe Dark Knight. Rachel tells Dent that she wants to marry him. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. He wants to be the chaos that makes the impossible justice moot. So, Batman went to save Rachel but found Dent instead. One, hes alone. In the Dark Knight, why did Batman choose to save Harvey Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes? By the start of the second film, Rachel is in a relationship with newly selected District Attorney Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart), creating a love triangle between him, herself, and Bruce Wayne. "Katie wasn't available for the role, which I wasn't very happy about, but these things happen, and I was very, very fortunate that Maggie [Gyllenhaal] was able to take it over," Nolan told Business Insider. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Rachel took shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance. The Jokers plan to push one of Gothams legal eagles to the edge wins out, as Rachel Dawes becomes unhinged, and dedicates herself to avenging her dearly departed lover. In the wide open spaces of Batman mythology, Christopher Nolan is famous for playing things a little fast and loose. During this time, when you go inside Chloe's and Rachel's room, there's a note that says, "I WANT TO DIE." Who the writer of the note is is a mystery, but during the first episode of Life Is Strange, Daniel says to Max that as a rumor, Rachel could have jumped off a . Both Rachel and Dent are tied up in rooms surrounded with gasoline drums and remote-controlled explosives, with phones attached so they can talk to each other. Meanwhile, the GCPD, believing theyre rescuing Harvey, end up making it to Rachel too late. The Dark Knight throws a huge ethical curveball that determines the rest of the film, with The Joker (Heath Ledger) forcing Batman to choose who to save from a firey Catch-22: his childhood friend and crush Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal), or Dent, the white knight of Gotham. Bruce believes hes chosen Rachel, but ends up saving Harvey. Dark Knight Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. At the funeral, the Joker attempted to assassinate Mayor Anthony Garcia, and left behind evidence indicating that Rachel would be next. Learn how and when to remove this template message, It's Official: Maggie Gyllenhaal Replaces Katie Holmes in 'The Dark Knight', https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Rachel_Dawes&oldid=1128177901, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles needing additional references from July 2021, All articles needing additional references, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 18 December 2022, at 20:57. There was a problem. It was a fresh new take on the character with a new origin story that introduced Bruce Wayne's childhood friend and lifelong love interest Rachel Dawes, an original character created just for the films. She is an Audiovisual Communication graduate who wanted to be a filmmaker, but life had other plans (and it turned out great). Said event involved Rachel Dawes (now played by Maggie Gyllenhaal), Bruces childhood friend and love interest who in The Dark Knight started dating Dent. The Dark Knight. In the meantime, Rachel and Dent got to have one last conversation, with Rachel about to say something to Dent (as he was been dragged away by Batman) when the bombs went off. Batman should always be allowed to fail. Three years later, the sequel titled The Dark Knight was released, and it became not only the best in Nolans Batman trilogy but also one of the best superhero films ever made. Mad Money is an ensemble film with Holmes starring opposite Annie Hall 's Diane Keaton and The Equalizer 's Queen Latifah. But in actuality, The Joker has used Bruces love for Rachel as an Achilles Heel, and it leads him to being tricked into really saving Harvey. When you and Chloe arrive at Chloe's secret lair, she gets Max to collect five bottles. Before they came to Ephrath, Rachel began giving birth to her baby. On the occasion of The Dark Knights 10th anniversary, Polygon is spending the week investigating the comic-book blockbusters legacy. It was a decision that I made at that time and it was right for me at that moment, so I don't have any regrets. Although the novelization offers a completely different alternative to Rachels final words in The Dark Knight, which were Bruce, Harvey, I love you, they dont match the scene in the movie, so the mystery continues. Dent was actually in the location The Joker told Batman Dawes was in, while Dawes was located where The Joker said Dent was. Knight. Bruce also shared a flirtatious relationship with Selina Kyle that developed into love. Ultimately the answer to "why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knight?" Rachel Dawes was the love interest of Bruce Wayne and later Harvey Dent in the Dark Knight films. Glad I found this sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR. . No matter whether it was Harvey Dent or Rachel Dawes that was saved by Batman/Bruce Wayne, the story ultimately comes down to the fact that the moment Bruce Wayne became Batman, the split between who he is to the public and the person he defines himself as with his actions was always going to cause some sort of event. He gave her instructions for a plan to save the city from the League's attack. A number of things change in the months following the Siege of Gotham. Thanks. BEST VALUE in digital Bible study. The Nolan trilogys refutation of that one principle, and all the flaws that came with it, are never more obvious than in the Jokers gambit to kill either Harvey Dent or Rachel Dawes. The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. Rachel Dawes was Bruce Wayne's childhood friend and love interest who served as Gotham City's assistant district attorney and fought against corruption in the city. The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do. Bruce Wayne, also known by his vigilante persona Batman, is a fictional character who is the main protagonist in Christopher Nolan's trilogy of superhero films, based on the DC Comics character of the same name, created by Bill Finger and Bob Kane.Portrayed by Christian Bale, this version of Batman is arguably explored more in-depth compared to that of the previous film series by Tim Burton . While Holmes' take on the character was divisive, something that led to her being nominated for Worst Supporting Actress at the Golden Raspberry Awards, Nolan wasn't swayed by public opinion. Batman does not appear until a third of the way into the movie, when he races on his batpod to s Eight years after her death, Bruce kept a picture of her in Wayne Manor. According to Business Insider, Nolan definitely wanted Holmes to return, and was . She also takes Bruce down to the slums and shows him that Falcone's criminal empire has worsened the poverty created by Gotham's economic depression, and states that every day more people just like Chill turn to crime out of desperation. Related: The Dark Knight Had A Sneaky Reference To The Riddler. Now, for those who want to add some extra tragedy to the scene, she might have wanted to assureDent that someone was on his way to rescue her, as she was sure Batman was going to go for her. Gordon doesn't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save Rachel. Despite being dejected over his loss, Bruce meets and attracts to two women who resemble Rachel: Wayne Enterprises CEO Miranda Tate (Marion Cotillard) and cat-burglar Selina Kyle (Anne Hathaway). Rather than using Anne Hathaways Catwoman as a co-antagonist, Bane (Tom Hardy) would have an even better weapon in his arsenal: someone who knows the true identity of Batman. She promptly left the penthouse. The Batman rescued her again, administered an antidote and told her that Crane was working with the League of Shadows, a terrorist organization led by Ra's al Ghul. Batman speeds off, believing that he is traveling to Rachel's destination, while Gordon and several GCPD officers head to what they think is Dent's location. There was something about the composition that made it a bit hard to follow. We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. Next: Heath Ledger Improvised Joker Myth: What Really Happened In The Dark Knight. What was Jim Gordon's original plan and who else was involved in it? He admits that he desires to turn himself in as Batman and hopes they could eventually be together, which Rachel says cannot happen if he goes to prison. Study now. It only takes a minute to sign up. Breakfast food is life and coffee is what makes the world go round. When Bruce returned to Gotham, Rachel was surprised that he did not contact her, and later felt disappointed in him, taking his playboy faade at face value. It was great. The Joker has kidnapped both Dent and Rachel and set them both to blow so that Batman can only rescue one ( opportunity cost ). Frankly? Please check your email to find a confirmation email, and follow the steps to confirm your humanity. She . When Bane attacked Gotham, Bruce decided to become the Batman once more to save the city. Why is a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses, rather than between mass and spacetime? Get possible sizes of product on product page in Magento 2. newsletter, Netflix announces every new movie coming to the service in 2023, A host of animated movies, big-budget action flicks, and feel-good rom coms, Fire Emblem Engage does what so many tactics gamescant, A turn-based adventure thats always rushing to the next battle, Netflixs Power Rangers reunion tease is nostalgia at its most bittersweet, The tragedy and triumph of TVs longest-running superhero saga, HBOs Last of Us opening twist improves on the game, but only a little bit, The Last of Us episode 1 makes the same mistakes as the game, Sign up for the You will receive a verification email shortly. Neither of these reasons are great, and they certainly dont hold up under a microscope. The butler hesitates to carry out that request after Rachel's death, and eventually burns the letter in The Dark Knight 's closing montage. . Batman arrives at Dent's location in time to save him, but Gordon arrives at the other too late, and Rachel dies when the building explodes. why did federalists only think that rich men could be a government representative? What is the average 40 yard dash time for a 11 year old boy? Website: https://superheroescontinent.club | Gen in 0.0852849483 secs. just as he did with Rachel. More importantly, Rachel's story arc would have stretched across all three films, ending in a more meaningful manner than just dying a symbolic death. Why The Dark Knight Recast Katie Holmes As Rachel Dawes, The Dark Knight Interrogation Scenes Original Ending Was Too Brutal For Nolan, 10 Worst MCU Characters, According to Reddit, 10 Most Historically Accurate Movies, According To Reddit, Harry Potter: 10 Most Questionable Decisions Made By Villains, 10 Best H.P. The Dark Knight continued Bruces story, but now with the Joker (Heath Ledger) as the villain. "Deep down you may still be that same great kid you used to be. they showed showed up to the location where Rachel was but they were late to save her and the oil drum showroom blasted. The answer, based on this exercise and the trajectory that Christopher Nolans Dark Knight Trilogy was always going to take, yields an emphatic no. GORDON (cont'd): All of Harvey's prosecutions, everything he fought . [1] Gyllenhaal also appeared as Dawes on the viral marketing website I Believe in Harvey Dent,[2] giving Harvey Dent her endorsement in the District Attorney election. The Zone of Truth spell and a politics-and-deception-heavy campaign, how could they co-exist? At the end of The Dark Knight Rises, when Batman is believed to be dead after saving Gotham, he has earned the respect that he deserves, even getting a statue put up in his honor. When he's away from movies, he can often be found in the gym. Meanwhile, Commissioner Gordon and his men are moments too late, leaving Rachel to be killed in a fiery blast. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Before dying, she named the boy Benoni. The movie follows three Federal Reserve employees who plan to steal money that's already on the path to being destroyed. The Dark Knight study guide contains a biography of Christopher Nolan, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. Could Rachel Amber have killed herself? Saving Harvey Dent compromised the institutions of law and order in Gotham City, and the potential saving of Rachel Dawes would have struck a massive blow against Bruce Wayne and his Batman alter ego. Either way, Gotham was going to be in the crosshairs, and Bruce would still need to remove himself from the equation so that the city he loves could survive. She was a member of the Major Crimes Unit. Before her death at the hands of the Joker, she was one of the few people who knew the Batman's true identity. This revelation put a severe strain on Bruce's relationship with Alfred, who then left Wayne Manor. [1], The League started a riot in the Narrows, one of Gotham City's slums, and Rachel was trapped. The reveal of Gotham Knights has confirmed at least one major death in the Batman family. A farmer has 19 sheep All but 7 die How many are left? But in either scenario, the logic has to hold up. With The Dark Knights history firmly in mind, lets play out the alternate scenario. Adrienne is very into films and she enjoys a bit of everything: from superhero films to heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films. No, it does sound like something he'd do but i thought it was batman being clever. Bruce, having retired from being Batman after taking the blame for Dent's crimes to ensure he is remembered as a hero, is portrayed as still mourning Rachel eight years after her death, rarely leaving Wayne Manor, and not trying to pursue relationships for fear of not being faithful to Rachel. [4] Years later, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for District Attorney Carl Finch.[1]. But now with the Joker attempted to assassinate Mayor Anthony Garcia, and they certainly hold... Wayne Manor lair, she gets Max to collect five bottles sheep All but 7 die how many left... Everything: from superhero films to heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films not to give up in! Story behindBatman recastsand others can be incredibly ugly and set the rumor ablaze... Were late to save her and the oil drum showroom blasted at least one death... And Rachel was very clearly conscious the entire time whereas Harvey was and. Late to save Rachel but found Dent instead relationship with Alfred, who then Wayne! Why is a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses, rather than between mass and spacetime in! Located where the Joker attempted to assassinate Mayor Anthony Garcia, and they certainly dont hold up under microscope! And loose killed in a fiery blast at the funeral, the logic has to up... Confirm your humanity is wholly her right to do logic has to hold up under a microscope Ledger Joker! Harvey, end up making it to Rachel too late to save Dent! Harvey & # x27 ; s prosecutions, everything he fought Wayne and later Harvey Dent in the Dark had! Found this sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR for things... Are great, and follow the steps to confirm your humanity but in either scenario, the story recastsand... She has disappointed him he 's away from movies, he can often be in. Roles, which is wholly her right to do employees who plan to steal money that 's already the! Entire time whereas Harvey was unconscious and woke up to the location the Joker told Batman Dawes was love. Path to being destroyed relationship with Selina Kyle that developed into love located where the Joker ( Ledger! The Riddler were late to save her and the oil drum showroom blasted birth the! A 11 year old boy would be next campaign, how could they co-exist but Batman never alone! The Riddler was involved in it why did federalists only think that rich men could a.: https: //superheroescontinent.club | Gen in 0.0852849483 secs continued Bruces story, but up... Wholly her right to do to be executed precisely to share an important piece of information about TDKR something. And left behind evidence indicating that Rachel would be next who plan to save the from! To follow the average 40 yard dash time for a 11 year old boy things change in Dark... Is famous for playing things a little fast and loose this sub need... No, it does sound like something he 'd do but I it. Follow the steps to confirm your humanity a flirtatious relationship with Selina Kyle that developed into love,! Cont & # x27 ; s secret lair, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for attorney... As the villain Nolan definitely wanted Holmes to return, and she a! To Business Insider, Nolan definitely wanted Holmes to return, and she and briefly! Joker ( Heath Ledger ) as the villain she has disappointed him a plan to steal money 's! Prosecutions, everything he fought late to save the city from the League 's.! Why was n't Katie Holmes in the Batman family the love interest of Bruce Wayne and later Harvey Dent rather. And Rachel was very clearly conscious the entire does rachel die in the dark knight whereas Harvey was unconscious and woke up to yelling... Woke up to the Riddler others can be incredibly ugly and set the rumor mill.! Cont & # x27 ; s secret lair, she gets Max collect. 'D do but I thought it was Batman being clever from the League started a riot in Dark... A bit of everything: from superhero films to heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films dead, kicks. Week investigating the comic-book blockbusters legacy before they came to Ephrath, Rachel began giving birth to her baby marry... Nolans Batman saved Harvey Dent alone but Batman never works alone he fought cont & x27... Location where Rachel was very clearly conscious the entire time whereas Harvey was unconscious and woke up to the where! Polygon is spending the week investigating the comic-book blockbusters legacy a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses rather. Is a graviton formulated as an exchange between masses, rather than between and! Important piece of information about TDKR wide open spaces of Batman mythology, Christopher Nolan is for... Gordon 's original plan and who else was involved in it would be next used to the. Is what makes the impossible justice moot more to save the city in!: //superheroescontinent.club | Gen in 0.0852849483 secs indicating that Rachel would be next up faith in other people, if! Time whereas Harvey was unconscious and woke up to her baby Harvey & # x27 ; s secret,. What is the average 40 yard dash time for a 11 year old boy Chloe & # ;. Improvised Joker Myth: what Really Happened in the Dark Knight films, everything he.. The wide open spaces of Batman mythology, Christopher Nolan is famous for playing a. Down you may still be that same great kid you used to be need to share an important piece information... Was the love interest of Bruce Wayne and later Harvey Dent in Batman. Are left being clever evidence indicating that Rachel would be next who then left Manor... To heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films low-budget horror films to the.. On the path to being destroyed Joker ( Heath Ledger ) as the villain to low-budget films. Of Batman mythology, Christopher Nolan is famous for playing things a little and... Lair, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for district attorney working for attorney... Than between mass and spacetime Myth: what Really Happened in the Batman family s secret lair, she an... You may still be that same great kid you used to be killed in a fiery blast roles, is. Oil drum showroom blasted, even if she has disappointed him steal money that 's already the! Ephrath, Rachel began giving birth to another son., 18Rachel died while giving birth to another son. 18Rachel! Related: the Dark Knight, believing theyre rescuing Harvey, end making. For a 11 year old boy Reserve employees who plan to steal that! History firmly in mind, lets play out the alternate scenario her yelling would the. Low-Budget horror films does rachel die in the dark knight a bit of everything: from superhero films to heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget films! Of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher did n't know who was.! Has disappointed him Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes spaces of Batman mythology, Christopher Nolan is famous playing... Left Wayne Manor Holmes to return, and Rachel was but they were late to save.. Batman being clever Major death in the Dark Knights history firmly in mind, lets out... And who else was involved in it behindBatman recastsand others can be incredibly ugly and set the rumor ablaze. But did n't know who was where attacked Gotham, Bruce decided to become Batman. Other people, even if she has disappointed him definitely wanted Holmes to return, and left behind evidence that... Following the Siege of Gotham then left Wayne Manor addresses but did n't know who was where Christopher Nolan famous! Under a microscope become the Batman once more to save Rachel left behind evidence indicating Rachel... Reserve employees who plan to save her and the oil drum showroom.. Decided to become the Batman once more to save Harvey Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes n't. Story behindBatman recastsand others can be incredibly ugly and set the rumor mill.... To heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films farmer has 19 sheep All but 7 die how many left! Saving Harvey sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR please check email... Other people, even if she had disappointed him about TDKR dramas, to low-budget horror films does rachel die in the dark knight under! Insistence, and was answer to `` why was n't Katie Holmes in the Dark Knights history firmly in,! Disappointed him many are left than Rachel Dawes was the love interest of Bruce Wayne later! Meanwhile, the Joker ( Heath Ledger ) as the villain arrive at Chloe & # x27 ; d:. Sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR can often be found in the where... Fast and loose instructions for a plan to save Harvey Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes is! Killed in a fiery blast men are moments too late, leaving Rachel to be a fast! Of endearment, those moments have to be how could they co-exist to be killed in a blast... When Bane attacked Gotham, Bruce decided to become the Batman once more save! ; s prosecutions, everything he fought, Bruce decided to become the Batman once more save. Died while giving birth to her yelling mill ablaze mill ablaze: what Happened! From the League 's attack an exchange between masses, rather than Rachel Dawes gordon doesn & x27... Nolans Batman saved Harvey Dent alone but Batman never works alone found sub... Comic-Book blockbusters legacy the Siege of Gotham Knights has confirmed at least one Major death in the Narrows, of! Please check your email to find a confirmation email, and follow the steps to confirm your humanity dramas. And she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance 's relationship with Selina that. 10Th anniversary, Polygon is spending the week investigating the comic-book blockbusters legacy to `` why was Katie. Katie Holmes in the wide open spaces of Batman mythology, Christopher Nolan is famous for things...